How much house you can afford in Florida comes down to what a lender will approve and what your take-home pay can carry. Then there are the Florida costs that sit on top of the mortgage.
When Joe and I sat down with lender Paul Godbout of New American Funding in July 2026, his advice about take-home pay stuck with us: budget from what you bring home, not from your gross.
Everything below reflects that July 2026 discussion, with a few public benchmarks added. Rates and programs change, and none of this is an offer. Talk to a licensed lender about your situation.
How much will a lender approve you for?
On most loans, total debt payments can reach about half of your gross monthly income. Paul’s comfort level is closer to 38%.
Fannie Mae’s guide caps the debt-to-income ratio at 50% for loans run through its automated underwriting (Fannie Mae). Paul told us FHA and VA loans can sometimes stretch to 57% to 60%. Then he ran the numbers, and those limits looked very different.
Take a household earning $120,000 a year, or $10,000 a month. At 50%, Paul could approve a $5,000 monthly payment. But taxes come out first. If 28% goes to Uncle Sam, that leaves $7,200. After a $5,000 payment, only $2,200 remains for everything else: gas, food, phones, utilities.
That’s tight.
It’s why Paul aims for about 38% and suggests bringing in a financial advisor at the start.
In 26 years, he said, the biggest mistake he’s seen is people budgeting from gross income. They come up short, lean on credit cards and end up calling back for an equity line.
What do mortgage rates do to your price range?
A lot. A one-point move in rates changes the loan amount a given payment can carry by roughly 10%.
In late July 2026, Paul put rates anywhere from the high 5s to the low 7s, depending on the program and loan type. He believed they were tracking oil prices and news from the Middle East because traders expected higher oil prices to feed inflation. For a public benchmark, Freddie Mac’s weekly average for a 30-year fixed mortgage was 6.58% on July 23, 2026, and 7.03% on September 24 (Freddie Mac).
Here’s the principal-and-interest payment per $100,000 borrowed on a 30-year fixed loan, based on our math:
| Rate | Per $100,000 | On a $500,000 loan |
|---|---|---|
| 6.00% | $600 | $2,998 |
| 6.50% | $632 | $3,160 |
| 7.00% | $665 | $3,327 |
| 7.25% | $682 | $3,411 |
The payment that carries a $500,000 loan at 6% carries only about $450,000 at 7%. Paul’s point in the video was simple: when rates jump, you bring more cash or shop for less house. Our video example was a $650,000 home with $150,000 down, leaving a $500,000 loan.
What does a Florida home cost to own beyond the mortgage?
Start with property tax, insurance and any association charges. In Florida, each works differently than it does up north.
Property tax resets when you buy. The seller’s bill reflects their exemptions and caps, not yours. On the $650,000 example, we estimated about $7,500 a year, including school taxes. Rates vary by district. Here are 2025 examples in Lee County (Lee County Property Appraiser):
| Inside city limits of | Total 2025 rate | Per $500,000 of taxable value |
|---|---|---|
| Bonita Springs | 12.797 mills | About $6,400 |
| Cape Coral | 15.3806 mills | About $7,690 |
| Fort Myers | 16.5034 mills | About $8,250 |
If the home is your permanent residence on January 1, the 2026 homestead exemption takes up to $51,411 off the value for non-school taxes and $25,000 for school taxes. Save Our Homes then limits later increases to 2.7% for 2026 (Lee County Property Appraiser, Florida DOR).
A second home gets neither benefit. Its assessed value can rise by up to 10% a year for non-school taxes (Lee County Property Appraiser).
A larger homestead exemption, Amendment 3, was on the November 3, 2026 ballot and needed 60% to pass (Florida Senate). Check the Florida Division of Elections for the result and your property appraiser for how it applies.
Insurance depends more on the house than on the headlines. Citizens cut its homeowners multiperil rates for 2026 by an average of 8.8% (Citizens), but annual increases can reach 50% on non-primary homes, compared with a 15% cap for primary residences (Citizens).
Lenders require flood insurance on federally backed loans for buildings in high-risk A and V zones (FloodSmart). As of September 30, 2026, NFIP authorization ran through December 11, 2026 (FEMA). Citizens’ flood requirement extends to all its personal residential policies except condo units on January 1, 2027 (Citizens). The full breakdown is in what insurance really costs in Southwest Florida.
Then there’s the association math. In our June 2026 video, Joe put typical HOA fees in master-planned communities at $200 to $1,500 a month and CDD assessments at $1,500 to $4,000 a year (video). CDD charges appear on the county tax bill (Chapter 190), but the August TRIM notice leaves them out. So the November bill runs higher (Lee County Tax Collector).
In the video, we used Bonita Bay as an example. Some high-rise condos there carried $30,000 to $40,000 a year in fees, compared with $4,000 to $6,000 for a single-family home in the same community. If you’ll be away part of the year, add home watch, a service that checks the house and makes sure the AC hasn’t quit. Compare fee structures on HOA and amenity communities.
How is a second-home mortgage different?
It usually costs more. Some programs aren’t available, and the loan carries extra pricing.
I asked Paul about this because so many of our buyers are purchasing second homes here. He gave two reasons. Some owner-occupied programs that discount the rate or closing costs aren’t available for a second home. A few years ago, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac also began pricing second homes closer to investment properties, with loan-level adjustments based on down payment and credit score.
That change traces back to FHFA’s January 2022 decision to add upfront fees of 1.125% to 3.875% on second-home loans, effective April 1, 2022 (FHFA).
Paul also described a path some buyers take. If you’ll truly live in the Florida home for more than six months of the year, you may finance it as your primary residence and keep or rent the house up north. Occupancy is a signed statement on your loan application, so go through the rules with your lender before choosing. Joe’s second home guide covers the rest of the snowbird math.
For rentals, Paul explained DSCR loans. These qualify based on the property’s expected rent, using figures from the appraiser or a short-term rental data service, rather than your income. He mentioned financing up to about 80% of value, sometimes more, as long as the rent covers the payment and you have assets and good credit.
Can you put less than 20% down and skip PMI?
Sometimes. In the video, Paul described a conventional option with 15% down and no private mortgage insurance, and we cut that section into a Short. One of us guessed PMI could otherwise run $150 to $200 a month.
Paul added that no-monthly-PMI options may allow up to 95% financing, especially for borrowers with very high credit scores. The insurance may be paid as a one-time lump sum or by the lender. It can also be split, with part paid up front and a smaller monthly charge. That was Paul’s description in July 2026, not an offer, and eligibility varies.
When should you get pre-approved?
Before you tour. Paul puts it bluntly: if you’re not approved to buy the houses you’re looking at, you’re wasting everybody’s time.
He starts with a soft credit pull, so there’s no hard inquiry. Once you have a property and the full credit report is pulled, it’s good for 120 days. That gives you roughly 90 days to shop and 30 to close.
Keep your credit clean in between. Don’t change jobs. And no new F-150.
Paul made the case for having a buyer’s agent, too. Without one, he said, you’re going into the transaction “naked and exposed,” especially here in Southwest Florida (Short). You’re free to use any lender you like. Our finance page explains how to reach Paul. Once you know your number, browse communities or homes.
