Moving from New York or New Jersey to Southwest Florida can sharply cut your state income tax bill. But both states make you earn the exit. New York keeps your domicile until you prove you’ve left, and keeping a New York apartment can make you a resident anyway. New Jersey requires an estimated tax payment at closing if you’re a nonresident when you sell. Both states can still tax real estate you keep there.
This is general information, not tax or legal advice. These rules are why we recommend speaking with a New York or New Jersey tax professional before setting a move date.
How much state income tax are you leaving behind?
The top state income tax rates for 2025 are 10.9% in New York and 10.75% in New Jersey. New York City adds its own tax. Florida has no personal income tax (Art. VII, s. 5) and no estate tax (Florida DOR).
| New York | New Jersey | Florida | |
|---|---|---|---|
| State income tax rates (2025) | 4% to 10.9% | 1.4% to 10.75% | None |
| Local income tax | NYC residents pay 3.078% to 3.876% more | None at the local level | None |
| Estate tax | Yes. Exclusion of $7,350,000 for 2026 deaths | None for deaths since Jan. 1, 2018 | None |
| Inheritance tax | None | 11% to 16% for some heirs (Class C and D) | None |
| Tax when a nonresident sells a home | Estimated payment (IT-2663), with a principal-residence exemption | Estimated payment (GIT/REP) unless exempt | Not applicable |
Sources: New York’s 2025 IT-201 instructions and estate tax page; New Jersey’s 2025 NJ-1040 rate schedules and inheritance and estate tax page.
When does New York stop treating you as a resident?
When you can show you’ve abandoned your New York domicile and set up a new one. The Tax Department says “your New York domicile does not change until you can demonstrate that you have abandoned your New York domicile and established a new domicile outside New York State.” Domicile is the place you intend to return to after being away, and you only get one.
Our residency guide for snowbirds covers the day-count tests New York and New Jersey apply, what New York auditors look at, and the Florida steps in order: a Florida driver license within 30 days, vehicle registration within 10, voter registration, a declaration of domicile and a homestead filing by March 1. This post sticks to what that one doesn’t: the taxes that hit when you sell or leave property behind.
What if you keep an apartment in New York?
Then two New York taxes can follow the property, on top of the 184-day statutory residency test for anyone who keeps a New York home for more than 11 months of the year.
- A nonresident’s estate must file a New York estate tax return if it includes New York real or tangible property and the federal gross estate plus certain gifts exceeds the basic exclusion, which is $7,350,000 for 2026.
- When a nonresident sells New York real property, Form IT-2663 requires an estimated income tax payment when the deed is recorded. A sale that qualifies in full as your principal residence under federal rules is exempt.
What does New Jersey collect when you sell the house?
New Jersey collects a prepayment if you’re a nonresident on the closing date. Its GIT/REP rules require nonresident sellers to make an estimated Gross Income Tax payment at closing. The payment is the gain multiplied by the top rate of 10.75%, but never less than 2% of the sale price shown on the deed.
It isn’t a separate tax. You report the actual gain on the NJ-1040NR and receive a refund for anything paid beyond what you owe. Still, it’s real cash held at closing, and the order of events decides whether the payment applies. Sellers who maintain a permanent New Jersey residence on the transfer date can claim the resident exemption on Form GIT/REP-3.
The year you move, New Jersey has no part-year return, so you may file both the NJ-1040 and the NJ-1040NR (NJ-1040 instructions).
Does New Jersey tax an estate after you’ve moved?
New Jersey’s estate tax ended for deaths on or after January 1, 2018. The state still has an inheritance tax of 11% to 16% on property left to certain heirs. It can apply even when the person lived elsewhere but owned New Jersey real estate.
Who inherits decides it. Class A beneficiaries include a spouse or civil union partner, children, grandchildren and parents, and they receive preferential treatment. Siblings and sons- or daughters-in-law fall in Class C (beneficiary classes). If you keep a shore house and plan to leave it to a sibling, talk with an estate attorney.
How do the property tax bills compare?
Florida usually comes out ahead once you have homestead. In his June 2026 video, my business partner Joe gave a practical comparison: a $750,000 house in Bergen County might carry an annual property tax bill of $15,000 to $20,000. A house at the same price in Estero might run roughly $7,500 to $9,000, depending on the community.
There’s a catch. The Florida bill resets based on your purchase price, so the seller’s bill shown with a listing is a poor guide to what you’ll pay.
Amendment 3 was on the November 3, 2026 ballot and needed 60% approval. As written, it raises the non-school homestead exemption to $150,000 in 2027 and $250,000 in 2028 for people who were permanent Florida residents by December 31, 2026. Newer residents receive a smaller exemption during their first years (Florida Senate). Check the Florida Division of Elections for the result.
Gulf Coast or Palm Beach?
Visit both before deciding. Joe gets a call every week from someone in New York or New Jersey considering the stretch around Boca, Palm Beach and Delray without having visited the Gulf side.
His short version from the video: Florida’s East Coast is denser and busier. The Gulf Coast, from Cape Coral down to Marco Island, has calmer water and a slower pace. We covered the differences in 5 hard truths about moving to Southwest Florida.
The IRS numbers show where New York and New Jersey movers who changed their filing addresses went in 2022–23 (county migration data):
| Origin county | To Lee County | To Collier County |
|---|---|---|
| Suffolk, NY | 433 | 234 |
| Nassau, NY | 224 | 208 |
| New York (Manhattan), NY | 109 | 137 |
| Westchester, NY | 125 | 128 |
| Monmouth, NJ | 184 | 182 |
| Bergen, NJ | 173 | 147 |
| Ocean, NJ | 221 | 111 |
Suffolk’s 433 was the second-largest total into Lee from any county outside Florida. Statewide, 71,476 people moved from New York to Florida that year, more than from any other state. Another 34,761 came from New Jersey.
If you want to walk to dinner, start with Naples around Fifth Avenue South and Third Street. For a Gulf view, look at beachfront properties and Marco Island, which is reached by bridge.
And if you’re considering a condo, read the firsthand note above and our 2026 condo rules guide. Florida gives resale condo buyers a 7-day cancellation window after they sign and receive the association documents, not counting weekends and holidays (s. 718.503).
How do you get back to New York and New Jersey?
By air. The Lee County Port Authority’s September 2026 Air Service Update listed these Fort Myers (RSW) routes:
| Airport | Airlines to RSW | Status |
|---|---|---|
| JFK | Delta, JetBlue | Not flagged seasonal |
| LaGuardia | Delta | Not flagged seasonal. American resumes seasonal service November 2026. |
| Newark | United | Not flagged seasonal |
| White Plains | JetBlue | Not flagged seasonal |
| Islip | Breeze | Not flagged seasonal. JetBlue resumes seasonal service November 2026. |
| Atlantic City | Breeze | New route from October 2026 |
| Trenton | Breeze | New route from January 2027 |
| Buffalo, Syracuse, Albany | JetBlue, Breeze, Breeze | Not flagged seasonal, with more seasonal service in winter |
Punta Gorda (PGD) adds Newburgh/Stewart and Niagara Falls (PGD). Driving from New York City to Naples is about 1,293 miles and 20.5 hours on I-95, based on a single Google Maps reading from September 30, 2026.
Is a Southwest Florida summer like a New York summer?
No. It’s longer and wetter.
NOAA’s 1991–2020 normals count 17 days a year at 90°F or hotter in Central Park and 28 at Newark. Fort Myers (RSW) averages 119 such days.
The July normals are 84.9°F and 70.1°F for Central Park, compared with 90.6°F and 74.8°F at RSW. Rain falls differently too. New York’s 49.5 inches are spread throughout the year, while RSW receives most of its 53.4 inches from June through September.
Winter is the payoff. January in Central Park averages a high of 39.5°F. At RSW, it’s 74.7°F.
When you’re ready to compare a Naples condo with a house in Bonita or Estero, browse current listings or reach out.
